Tim has provided his first-half fantasy All-Stars and honorable mentions by position. It’s a great list, and hopefully, you were able to draft or acquire some of these players during the first half.
Catcher
Cal Raleigh, SEA (ADP-79): When you have more home runs (38) than the combined total of the #2 and #3 ranked catchers, you’re having an incredible year. Sal Perez’s record 48 home runs in 2021 is well within reach for the “Big Dumper”.
Honorable Mention
Drake Baldwin, ATL (ADP-419): Baldwin is ranked #17 on the ESPN player rater, one spot above Sean Murphy. As a second catcher in two-catcher leagues, Baldwin was quickly taken from the free agent pool and is demonstrating why the future at catcher in Atlanta looks very promising.
Hunter Goodman, COL (ADP-317): One of the few success stories in Colorado this year, Goodman enters the break with 17 homers, 52 RBI, and a very surprising .282 BA. The power numbers aren’t a surprise, but did anyone see a .282 BA in his future?
Agustin Ramirez, MIA (ADP-441): Ramirez can flat out hit, with 14 homers and 40 RBI in his first 286 big league at-bats. The extra at-bats are coming from the DH spot, but the good news is that he’ll qualify as a catcher going into 2026.
Austin Wells, NYY (ADP-176): He entered the break with 14 homers (tied for 5th) and 53 RBI (4th). He’s looking like a Top 10 pick next Spring and a solid bargain this year in the early-teen rounds. Austin isn’t the first Wells to take New York by storm, but could prove to be the best?
First Base
Nick Kurtz, ATH (ADP-474): Kurtz had a slow start, hitting just one homer in his first 23 games. Over the next 37 games, he proved why he was hyped in the pre-season, blasting an impressive 17 home runs. He’s becoming one of the league’s most powerful sluggers right before our eyes, and as the 95th first baseman off the board this year, he’s a major win for Fantasy Managers. Jacob Misiorowski should have been pitching to Nick Kurtz in the 2025 All-Star Game.
Honorable Mention
Michael Busch, CHC (ADP-249): Very quietly, Michael Busch is enjoying a great 2025 with 19 homers, 59 RBI, and an off-the-charts .924 OPS. He’s 2nd in homers (one behind the leader), 4th in RBIs, and second only to Nick Kurtz in OPS. For those who gambled on the 24th pick at First Base, the rewards have been enormous.
Spencer Torkelson, DET (ADP-381): Spencer Torkelson was 35% rostered at CBS in Week 1. We hoped he would return to his 2023 form, and with 21 homers and 59 RBI at the break, mission accomplished.
Second Base
Brandon Lowe, TBR (ADP-213): Lowe only needs three homers in the second half to achieve his second-best HR total since his 2018 debut. The 19 homers and 50 RBI have been significant, especially considering he was the 20th second baseman taken with an ADP of 213.
Honorable Mention
Nico Hoerner CHC (ADP-191): Hoerner is currently second in stolen bases with 16. He is tied for third in runs scored with 52. He might generate very little hype, but with that level of production, he has more than earned his keep.
Shortstop
Zach Neto, ATH (ADP-195): In his second full season with the Angels, Zach Neto is demonstrating that his impressive 2024 season was no fluke. The 24-year-old has now hit 15 home runs, stolen 17 bases, and scored an impressive 62 runs. Being the 21st best at his position off-the-board shows his value.
Honorable Mention
Otto Lopez MIA (ADP-346): Lopez has 52 RBI at the break, placing eighth at shortstop. Add in the double-digit power and stolen bases, and you get a top-tier middle infielder at a bargain price.
Jeremy Pena HOU (ADP-160): Until the fractured rib at the end of July sent him to the IL, Jeremy Pena was having a standout year. His double-digit power and speed, along with a .332 BA, exceeded expectations and moved him into the top tier at shortstop.
Trevor Story BOS (ADP-253): Story is currently tied for fourth in home runs with 15 and tied for seventh in stolen bases with 17. Now fully healthy, Story is performing at a level we haven’t seen since his days in Colorado.
Jacob Wilson ATH (ADP-353): What Wilson lacks in power and speed, he more than compensates with his outstanding hitting ability.
Third Base
Eugenio Suarez, ARZ (ADP-160): Eugenio Suarez is the Rodney Dangerfield of Third Base types. He simply gets no respect. Going all the way back to 2016, his first full season, Suarez has mashed 21, 26, 34, 49, 15, 31, 31, 22, and 30 home runs. He was 14th off-the-board in 2025 drafts and already has 31 home runs and 78 RBI in the bank. If you’re looking for power, and probably discounted power at that, move a bit early next Spring and reap the rewards.
Honorable Mention
Junior Caminero TBR (ADP-80): The 22-year-old is performing in a way that shows he could be a star, or even a super-star, for many years to come. In his first full season in the big leagues, Caminero enters the break with 25 homers and 64 RBI. You can bet the farm that he won’t be available in the 6th round next spring.
Outfield
Jo Adell, LAA (ADP-287): On June 8, we highlighted Jo Adell in our weekly Waiver Wire Article. He was coming off a strong stretch where he had hit five home runs over the past two weeks and was only rostered at 17% on CBS. He was swinging well then and hasn’t slowed down, as he hits the break with 20 home runs and 56 RBI. A small bid has yielded a big payoff.
Byron Buxton, MIN (ADP-218): I keep saying that one year, Byron Buxton will have a career year and not be on any of my teams. It looks like 2025 is that year.
Pete Crow-Armstrong, CHC (ADP-132): The ESPN Player Rater ranks Pete Crow Armstrong second, right behind Aaron Judge—and for good reason. With 25 homers, 71 RBI, 27 steals, and 67 runs scored, he’s had one of the best first-half performances on record.
Andy Pages, LAD (ADP-382): In Week Six, Andy Pages was rostered at 15% at CBS. Heading into the break, he has 17 home runs, 58 RBI, 7 steals, and a .283 batting average. He is currently ranked as the 20th best outfielder in the league. That return on investment will be hard to beat.
Kyle Stowers, MIA (ADP-479): Raise your hand if you were all-in on Stowers pre-season. I’ll raise mine, but it was for his debut campaign when he was coming up through the Orioles system. He started the season with a roster percentage of 2% at CBS, and by Week Six, that was only up to 21%. As a Waiver Wire addition, Stowers, with those 21 home runs, 59 RBI, and a .940 OPS (fifth best in all of baseball), has enjoyed an incredible first half and is likely to be on many Fantasy teams contending for a 2025 championship.
Honorable Mention
Sal Frelick, MIL (ADP-385): The power is just average, but Frelick makes up for it with 17 stolen bases and a great .354 OBP leadoff in Milwaukee.
Cedanne Rafaela, BOS (ADP-183): Rafaela has slugged 14 home runs and stolen 13 bases while playing excellent defense. He’s even walked one more time than he did all of 2024.
Seiya Suzuki, CHC (ADP-82): I always believed that Seiya Suzuki’s best years were still coming, and with 26 homers and 80 RBI at the halfway point, he’s proving it!
James Wood, WAS (ADP-50): The sky is the limit as he’s reaching for it in his sophomore season. Soon, he’ll secure a spot in the first round on draft day.
Starting Pitcher
Andrew Abbott, CIN (ADP-460): Sure, you can complain about the relatively low strikeout rate, but when you probably added him from the free agent pool early in the season and he contributed eight wins, a 2.07 ERA, and 1.08 WHIP to your first-half pitching stats, nobody is listening.
Matthew Boyd, DET (ADP-323): We’ve often wondered how good Matthew Boyd could be if he stayed healthy. We’ve found out in the first half of 2025.
Freddy Peralta, MIL (ADP-112): Peralta has always been a reliable #2 starter. In 2025, he has taken the next step and raised his game to “ace” level.
Nick Pivetta, SDP (ADP-192): After teasing us for years, Nick Pivetta finally delivered in the first half of 2025. A 2.88 ERA, 1.02 WHIP, 9 wins, and 122 strikeouts in 109 1/3 IP make that 13th-round gamble one of the best value picks of the 2025 season.
Honorable Mention
Yusei Kikuchi, LAA (ADP-168): Toronto was very good for Yusei Kikuchi, but Anaheim has been better. Robbie Ray, SFG (ADP-152): We were not really sure what to expect from Ray in 2025, but was anyone anticipating a career-best 2.65 ERA, nine wins, and 128 strikeouts in 119 first-half innings? He’s rekindling memories of that incredible 2021 season spent north of the 49th.
Cristopher Sanchez, PHI (ADP-167): Sanchez had an excellent first half, with 8 wins, a 2.50 ERA, and 122 strikeouts over 115 innings. He has boosted his value enough to be nearing Top-15 status heading into 2026.
Ranger Suarez, PHI (ADP-277): Those who doubted last year aren’t anymore. A 2.15 ERA and 1.06 WHIP, along with 7 wins, will turn anyone into a believer.
Logan Webb, SFG (ADP-103): After two consecutive years of trending downward, Webb has reversed course and, with 9 wins and potentially a career-best strikeout rate, is leading the charge in San Francisco.
Bryan Woo, SEA (ADP-142): He’s only 24 years old and is on track for back-to-back sub-3 ERA seasons. Paying for a #3 and ending up with a high-end #2 is a win every day and twice on Sunday.
Relief Pitcher
Emilio Pagan CIN (ADP-471): Remember when Alexis Diaz dominated the ninth inning in Cincinnati? He struggled and was replaced by Emilio Pagan, who came from the free agent pool to save 21 games in the first half. Is it time to sell high?
Honorable Mention
David Bednar, PIT (ADP-190): At the end of April, Bednar had a 5.14 ERA and two saves. At the break, his ERA improved to 2.53 with 13 saves. He’s back with a streak of 18 straight scoreless appearances dating back to May 24, proving it.
Aroldis Chapman, BOS (ADP-304): Chapman has posted a 1.18 ERA and .76 WHIP in the first half, a career best since his 2010 debut as a Red. There was definitely something left in the tank for 2025.
Daniel Palencia, CHC (ADP-450): How far down the pitching list was Daniel Palencia heading into 2025? He was the 196th pitcher off the board this spring. What a find for both the Cubs and those who plucked him out of the free agent pool in late May.
Will Vest, DET (ADP-485): Keep it close to the vest and enjoy the stellar first-half results.



You must be logged in to post a comment.